In response
to my own noticeable bias I decided to turn the tables on myself and find more
good things about race to the top, because there are some good things. This really was harder than finding the flaws
but these are things that RttT has done well.
These are the things the supports are saying about RttT.
·
Economically
the better jobs with higher pay require more skill so we need to better prepare
students to be able to acquire these better skills. “We have to educate ourselves to a better
economy.” – Arne Duncan
·
Common
Core – This is the first time students are being taught and measured the same in
elementary schools in Mississippi as they are in NYC. (45 states + D.C.) This
gives them all the same goal to reach so no one can low ball their
achievements.
·
There
is better accountability in the schools for their achievements and
failures. Schools want highly effective
teachers and test scores included in evaluations should help this. Ineffective teachers can no longer hide
behind tenure.
·
Promotes
collaboration between teachers unions, education reformers, legislators and
teachers.
·
RttT
has helped make education reform happen because of the ‘carrot’, money from
RttT instead of the ‘threat’ sanctions of NCLB.
·
Expansion
of charter schools has taken place all over the country. These are supposed to give students a better
option than struggling public schools, some are really successful.
·
Provides
teachers with more options and opportunities for professional development.
·
There
is a ‘carve out of funds’ for rural schools that would not be able to over
haul.
·
Individual
states determine if they want to compete and they decide which reforms to implement.
Here
locally the Race to the Top funds is being dedicated to teacher compensation
that will reward the outcomes of student growth. It is also funding leadership academies to
develop principles and expand teacher advancement programs and summer learning
camps for students.
I am afraid I am still biased! I wonder who is making these statements and where the facts and data are that back up their claims? For instance, "provides teachers with more options and opportunities for professional development?" Seriously, the teachers I've talked to are so snowed under with all the paperwork these new programs require that they hardly have time to complete their obligatory professional development credits. It is really going to be interesting to see how this all plays out!
ReplyDeleteGreat job in presenting other thoughts on this!